59% of you said that the method sucks.
26% say it's fair.
The other 15% have no opinion on the matter.
Personally, I find it completely misrepresenting of MLB's standard objectivity. If they cared, they'd give it to whoever has the best record. In the case of a tie, the advantage could go to the head-to-head winner during Interleague play or simply the team with the best Interleague record, if the two hadn't faced each other that season. But for some strange reason, I don't make those decisions.
In light of All-Star festivities beginning this week, our next poll is on the Home Run Derby, which will take place Monday night. Which one of these monsters is your favorite to win it all?
Feel free to go on the record in the comments!